Quick answer
Is a self-hosted VPN better than a commercial VPN?
Each wins a clear profile. A self-hosted server on TunnelVPS, from $2.25 a month on 12 months, wins for an address only you use and no device cap. A service such as Mullvad, at €5 a month, wins for many countries, shared exit addresses and no setup.
In brief
- Self-hosted wins on a dedicated address, free protocol choice and no device limit from the host.
- Commercial wins on country choice, shared exits that blend many users, and no upkeep.
- Price: Solo on 12 months is 59% under Mullvad's €5 a month; month to month it is dearer.
- Privacy: neither makes you anonymous; each moves trust from your provider to another party.
- Payment: TunnelVPS takes 7 coins; Mullvad and IVPN take Monero; ExpressVPN and Surfshark pages show no crypto.
How do prices and limits compare?
The commercial prices below are first-term prices from each service's own page. Renewal prices differ where the page states them.
| Option | Price shown | Renewal | Devices | Crypto on the page |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| TunnelVPS Solo (self-hosted) | $2.25 a month on 12 months ($27.00) | Same length at the order price | No limit set by TunnelVPS | BTC, USDT, USDC, ETH, SOL, LTC, XMR |
| Mullvad | €5 a month at any length | €5 a month | Up to 5 | Bitcoin, Bitcoin Cash, Monero; 10% off |
| Proton VPN Plus, 12 months | $2.99 a month, $35.88 first year | $83.88 every 12 months | 10 | Bitcoin via credits, after signup |
| ExpressVPN Basic, 28 months | €2.49 a month, €69.72 first term | €79.95 a year | 10 | Not mentioned on the order page |
| Surfshark Starter, 24 months | €2.49 a month, €67.23 for 27 months | Renewal price not shown | Unlimited | Not mentioned on the pricing page |
Prices checked on
Euro prices are kept in euros as the services show them. 1 EUR = 1.1216 USD (ECB reference rate of 2 November 2026) puts Mullvad at about $5.51.
When does a self-hosted VPN win?
When the address should belong to you, and setup is not a problem. A TunnelVPS server has one dedicated IPv4 rented by one account. No stranger's traffic leaves from it.
- Many devices. TunnelVPS sets no device limit; Mullvad allows 5 and Proton VPN Plus 10.
- Protocol choice. WireGuard, Outline or AmneziaWG; a service only offers its own list.
- A stable exit. The same address for the whole rental, useful for allow-lists.
- Long-term price. Solo on 12 months costs $2.25 a month, 59% under Mullvad.
The personal VPN server page explains how such a server works.
When does a commercial VPN win?
When you want many countries, a crowd to blend into, or no maintenance at all. These are real strengths, not marketing.
- Shared exits. Many customers leave from the same address, so one person's traffic is mixed with many others.
- Countries. Services run servers in many countries; a TunnelVPS server sits in one of six cities.
- No setup. Install an app, sign in, connect.
- Upkeep. The service patches its servers; a self-hosted owner patches their own.
- Free tier. Proton Free costs $0, with servers in 10 countries chosen at random.
The Mullvad comparison goes line by line.
Which is more private?
Neither is anonymous; they trust different parties. With a service, you trust its operator and blend with its users. With a self-hosted server, you trust the host, and the address points to one account.
A personal VPN hides traffic from the local network and the internet provider, not from the sites visited: every connection leaves through one IP address rented by one account, so it is a private tunnel, not anonymity. No KYC does not make a payment invisible: BTC, USDT, USDC, ETH, SOL and LTC payments sit on public blockchains, and while a Monero payment hides its sender and amount from block explorers, the TunnelVPS billing still links an account number to its orders, the IP addresses of its servers and the transaction ID of each payment.
One cost of a self-hosted server is the lack of a crowd. Its address belongs to one account, so activity from it ties to one renter over time. A shared exit blends you with other users.
A service that takes Monero and needs no email, such as Mullvad, keeps the payment side thin. TunnelVPS does the same with an account number and 7 coins, Monero included.
Which costs less over time?
Over 12 months, the self-hosted server; over one or two months, the service. TunnelVPS read Mullvad's pricing page on 16 November 2026: Solo on 12 months is 59% under Mullvad's monthly price. Month to month, Solo is $4.50, with a 3-month minimum: $13.50 for 3 months, the shortest term.
Watch renewals on the commercial side. Proton VPN Plus renews at $83.88 a year after a $35.88 first year. ExpressVPN Basic renews at €79.95 a year. A TunnelVPS server renews at the price of its order. The pricing page lists every length. The ExpressVPN alternatives page compares the two in more detail.
Self-hosted versus commercial VPN questions
Is self-hosting a VPN hard?
WireGuard takes a handful of commands over SSH; Outline and AmneziaWG are set up from their own apps. No VPN comes pre-installed: each server starts as a clean Debian or Ubuntu system. WireGuard installs with one documented command (sudo apt install wireguard), Outline is set up from the Outline Manager desktop app, and AmneziaWG from the AmneziaVPN app over SSH; the TunnelVPS guides walk through each one.
Can a self-hosted VPN change my country for streaming?
TunnelVPS makes no such promise. Geolocation databases decide on their own where a data-centre IP address sits, and streaming or banking sites may treat a data-centre address differently from a home one; TunnelVPS makes no promise about either.
Which has more exit locations?
A commercial service. A TunnelVPS server sits in one city: New York, Dallas, Los Angeles, London, Amsterdam or Frankfurt. A second server adds a second city.
Which is better for a family?
A self-hosted server if setup is fine: TunnelVPS sets no device limit, and Home costs $6.37 a month on 12 months. Surfshark also allows unlimited devices, with no setup.
Can a self-hosted VPN reach my home network or a service with an allow-list?
Yes, that is where it fits best. The server keeps one fixed IPv4 for the whole rental, so a firewall or a service can allow that address. A shared exit changes between connections.
Do commercial VPNs take crypto?
Some do. Mullvad and IVPN take Monero and Bitcoin. Proton sells credits for Bitcoin after signup. ExpressVPN and Surfshark pages read on 16 November 2026 did not mention crypto.
Verdict
- Self-host on TunnelVPS for an address only your devices use, no device cap and protocol choice, from $2.25 a month on 12 months.
- Choose Mullvad or another service for many countries, a shared exit and no upkeep.
- Pick by profile, not by slogan: both move trust, neither makes you anonymous.
Sources (6)
- Pricing mullvad.net/en/pricing — Mullvad (read 2026-11-16)
- Pricing protonvpn.com/pricing — Proton VPN (read 2026-11-16)
- Order expressvpn.com/order — ExpressVPN (read 2026-11-16)
- Pricing surfshark.com/pricing — Surfshark (read 2026-11-16)
- IVPN home page ivpn.net/en — IVPN (read 2026-11-16)
- Euro foreign exchange reference rates — European Central Bank (rate of 2026-11-02)
Try a self-hosted VPN from $2.25 a month
Your own server, your own address, any device count.
- Built by a person, 1 hour at most after confirmation
- Lost days credited back if a server cannot be delivered
- Pay in BTC, XMR, USDT, USDC, ETH, SOL or LTC
- DomaineGoat LLC · Panama